Reviews

MaybellineNew York Superstay Teddy Tint - Lip and Cheek Color | Keep It Cozy, 5 ml
4.5
23 Ratings7 Reviews
17
3
3
Review this product
Review this product
This isn't a simple average of the ratings received for the product. We calculate the product's ratings based on an algo which weighs the inputs from a Certified Buyer higher than the ratings from other customers. We understand this will help you make a more informed decision while placing an order for a product that you liked.
What customers say
(Tap on each bar to filter the reviews)
100%
100%
80%
100%
100%
Narrow Reviews By:
Customer Images (3)



8/5/2025
Worth the hunt
After a long search, I finally found the perfect lipstick in Maybelline's Keep It Cozy from the Teddy Collection. The warm, flattering shade is perfect for my light Indian skin tone, and the formula is lightweight, hydrating, and comfortable. It’s versatile for any occasion and truly worth the hunt!

3/3/2026
😭🤏🏽💋
This is the best liquid lipstick I’ve ever seen !!!😘🩶. After using this I can’t stop using it 😭😭😭 this thing didn’t make me to think to buy other lipstickssssss 😝🫶🏻🩶 I almost used 3 teddy tint of this shade called KEEP IT COZY!!!!🎀 everyone is asking me which shade are you wearing…😘🤏🏽 it’s thattttt dammmnnnn prettyyyy 🥹🤙🏾. When I wear other shade…I can’t get this tint’s beautyyyy🥹🥹🩶. Guysssss trust meeee this is a worthhhhh of money 🥹🩶🎀 and it’s texture….OMGGGGGG😝😝😝🤙🏾💋 it’s freaking amazingggggggggggggggg!!!! This is a must buy producttttt!!!!!🥹🥹🥹🥹🫶🏻🎀🎀🎀🩶🩶🩶

18/9/2025
Good Product 👍
The color is beautiful and natural. It stays long on lips and cheeks. Very smooth to apply and feels light. I really liked it, worth buying!
25/7/2025
nice product 👍♥️ thankyou purple
26/9/2025
keep it cozy
amazing on medium to light skin tone! love the nude shade

23/6/2025
keep it cozy
it is okay-okay. depends on how you apply it.
20/9/2024
false claimmmm
girlies I'm telling you if you are going to buy it cause of the hype you are wasting your money . like it's so hella sticky after applying it feels like I had applied glue stick on my lips and it's non transferproof. pls save yourself 🌧️🌧️