Reviews
MaybellineNew York Colossal Bold Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Black, 3 ml, Matte Finish
4.3
7384 Ratings2408 Reviews
4486
1739
505
201
453
Review this product
Review this product
This isn't a simple average of the ratings received for the product. We calculate the product's ratings based on an algo which weighs the inputs from a Certified Buyer higher than the ratings from other customers. We understand this will help you make a more informed decision while placing an order for a product that you liked.
What customers say
(Tap on each bar to filter the reviews)
87%
90%
95%
89%
81%
Narrow Reviews By:
Customer Images (351)
5/6/2026
I used dazzler eyeliner but it's not smudge proof. But this Maybelline newyork colossal bold pencil waterproof eyeliner is amazing product.. it is waterproof and smudge proof. And it worked really good. I recommend all to buy it❤️
6/9/2026
Long lasting super
4/8/2026
Very good eyeliner idont have words to🙏say superb
12/11/2025
Eye liner
too good.. my favorite also
20/5/2026
Good
Long lasting, bold black colour, easy to apply ♥️
10/7/2026
Nice 👌🏻
1 day ago
Nice eyeliner
Waterproof eye liner
5 days ago
Awesome
15 days ago
Nice
Nice product
13/10/2026
Good 👍😊
